Mastering MLB Prop Bets: Unpacking Performance Decrease in 2nd and 3rd Time Through the Order

When it comes to placing savvy Major League Baseball (MLB) prop bets, understanding the nuances of the game can make all the difference. One key concept that continues to gain attention from both bettors and analysts alike is the performance decrease of pitchers when facing batters for the 2nd and 3rd time through the order.

Understanding the Phenomenon

Before diving into how this phenomenon can influence your MLB prop bets, let’s first explore what it entails. Research has shown that starting pitchers, generally, have a less effective 2nd and 3rd time through the lineup. While this might not always be the case for the cream of the crop—like elite aces who maintain their dominance over the full game—it is a trend we see across the league.

In the first round through the order, pitchers often have the upper hand, making the most of their repertoire and mystery. However, as the game progresses, batters get a better sense of the pitcher’s style, delivery, and assortment, leading to a drop in the pitcher’s performance.

Utilizing this Insight in MLB Prop Bets

Now, how does this impact MLB prop bets? The key lies in being able to predict when this drop in performance will occur, and how significantly it will affect the game’s outcome.

Say you’re considering a prop bet on the number of total strikeouts a pitcher will have in a game. If the odds are high for a large number of strikeouts, but you know the pitcher tends to falter in later innings, it could be a good indicator to bet against the market. Similarly, you could use this knowledge when betting on total runs scored, as a decrease in pitcher performance could open the door for more runs later in the game. Furthermore, you can examine things from the opposing lineup’s perspective too. Certain lineups may have a particularly large increase in batting average from 1st time to 2nd and 3rd time through the order. Being aware of these subtleties can give you a leg up on casual bettors.

Potential Changes to Betting Strategies

This understanding of pitcher performance changes the way prop bets are placed. Traditionally, bettors might base their bets on a pitcher’s overall performance, but recognizing the decrease in effectiveness the 2nd and 3rd time through the order can inform more nuanced bets. One strategy could involve live betting. As you watch the game unfold, you can gauge a pitcher’s performance in real-time. If they’re beginning to show signs of decline during the 2nd time through the order, that could be your cue to place a bet predicting further decrease during the 3rd pass.


Understanding the intricacies of the game, like a pitcher’s performance decline during the 2nd and 3rd time through the order, can provide a significant edge when making MLB prop bets. It’s all about recognizing patterns, formulating strategies, and placing bets based on informed insights.

Remember, however, that while these patterns are helpful, they’re not set in stone. Every game is unique, and each pitcher-batter matchup brings its own dynamics. Nonetheless, the more you know about these nuances, the better you can predict and leverage them to maximize your prop betting success. Stay sharp, study the game, and let your knowledge guide your MLB prop betting strategies.

Share your love